What Are Innovation Tournaments and Why Are They Important? 

Innovation Tournaments is a framework that aims to enhance ideas generation to end up with exceptional opportunities. A major related publication to the frameworks is the book Innovation Tournaments: Creating and Selecting Exceptional Opportunities by Christian Terwiesch and Karl Ulrich.

The idea of an innovation tournament is to treat ideas as if they were competing in a tournament. In this, we can start with many participating ideas competing through different stages, resulting in one or a few final ideas.  ​

A simplified representation of an innovation tournament

Over different stages, the number of ideas will decrease as they get disqualified through filters and competitions, ensuring higher-quality ideas reach the tournament's end. Between each stage, you can design filters through which ideas get abandoned, recreated, or merged with others.  ​

What are the Advantages of Innovation Tournaments?

There are many reasons you would want to adopt an innovation tournament structure to your processes, here are a few: 
​

• Risk reduction: pursuing any innovative endeavor is risky. In a perfect non-existent situation, an organization would invest in one idea or pick one out of many after one filter. However, banking on one idea means a higher risk that our investment will not yield any returns. An innovation tournament structure reduces the risk by considering multiple ideas at each stage of the development.  
• Scalability: innovation tournaments can be easily scaled up and down to match the size of the participating members. Thus, it can be applied to a small team of few people or to an organization of 100+ people.  
• Avoids biases: Innovative ideas can originate from anywhere, and they should be judged on merit, not the person proposing them. A well-designed Innovation Tournament ensures that ideas are evaluated based on their quality and potential impact, minimizing the risk of decision biases and favoritism.
• ​Accommodates problem-solving and opportunity creation: Regardless of an organization's focus, whether it's finding solutions to pressing issues or seeking new business opportunities, Innovation Tournaments are versatile enough to fit the bill. They thrive both in scenarios where a problem needs a solution and where an opportunity is waiting to be discovered.

By harnessing these advantages effectively, Innovation Tournaments can become a powerful tool in accelerating an organization's innovative capacity and achieving strategic goals.

What are Filters That Can Go Between Stages?

Filters in an innovation tournament are essentially decision points that help sort through different ideas, determining which ones can move ahead to the next stage. They allow for ideas to be scanned, evaluated, and decided upon—whether they should be dismissed, fused with other ideas, or brought to the next round.

These filters can be tailored to the specific needs and priorities of the organization and can take on various forms:
​

• Quick checkpoints: Quick checkpoints are basic filters that provide rapid feedback, focusing on initial criteria like feasibility, relevance, and novelty. They are used to sift out ideas that do not meet the most fundamental criteria, allowing for more ideas to be eliminated efficiently.
• Group votes: These serve as democratic filters, allowing all participants or a certain panel to vote for the ideas they believe hold the most promise. This process ensures broad-based support and collective buy-in for the ideas that progress.
• Detailed studies and evaluations: As the tournament advances and as the stakes get higher, the filters can become more elaborate and detailed. They may incorporate comprehensive research, rigorous analysis, and even expert consultations. These filters ensure an in-depth understanding of the ideas, considering both potential risks and rewards.
• ​Prototyping and market testing: In the later stages, building prototypes or conducting small-scale market tests are invaluable filters. They allow the ideas to be tested in a more realistic setting, providing tangible evidence of the idea’s viability and usefulness.

The design of filters isn't static and is meant to change dynamically as per the evolution of the tournament. The investment in each idea increases as the tournament progresses, with each round of filters strategically designed to bring the tournament closer to its objective. By customizing these filters and using them judiciously, an organization can ensure an effective and efficient Innovation Tournament.

How to Design an Effective Innovation Tournament?

Creating a successful innovation tournament involves careful planning and design to fit each organization. However, here are some key components to consider:

1. Determine the objective: Before setting up an innovation tournament, clearly define the goals and the type of innovation sought. This helps direct participants' focus and ensures the results align with the organization's needs.
2. Set up clear guidelines: Establish a clear set of rules and guidelines that govern the tournament, addressing aspects such as participants' eligibility, confidentiality, submission criteria, and evaluation parameters.
3. Engage diverse participants: Encourage teams with a mix of skills and backgrounds to participate in the tournament. This promotes diversity of thought, leading to a richer pool of ideas.
4. Create a transparent evaluation process: Develop an unbiased evaluation process that is transparent to all participants. This will bolster trust in the tournament's outcomes and encourage greater participation.
5. Monitor progress: After the tournament, follow up on winning ideas by monitoring their progress and offering the necessary resources for successful implementation.

Embracing these strategies in designing your Innovation Tournament not only fosters a fair and encouraging environment for idea generation but also lays the foundation for the successful implementation of winning ideas, thus driving meaningful innovation within your organization.

Conclusion:

Innovation Tournaments offer a competitive, versatile framework for idea generation, reducing risk and improving diversity of thought. With tailored filters and transparent evaluation, these tournaments can be scaled to suit organizations of all sizes, catering to both opportunity identification and problem-solving ventures. To explore how Innovation Tournaments can benefit your organization, contact us, and let's discuss crafting a tailored approach to foster the innovation you need.

Contact Us